95pts- Robert Parker
94pts- James Halliday - 'Australian Wine Companion'
93pts- Wine Spectator
"A black, sexy beast, the 2004 Syrah Brookman (aged in 50% new French oak) offers up amazingly full-bodied, intense, blackberry fruit intermixed with notions of roasted coffee, flowers, & creme de cassis. Full-bodied, rich, beautifully textured, opulent, & long, it should drink well for 10-15 years." - Robert Parker
"Richer, riper, ....mocha & chocolate notes, & has good length with fine tannins & good acidity." - James Halliday
"Polished. Remarkably open in texture & focused in flavor, fine-grained tannins surrounding a pulsing core of blueberry, plum & wild berry flavors that linger effortlessly on the ever-so-slightly hot finish. Best from 2008 through 2020." - Wine Spectator